15.09.2026, 13:30

Search

Campaigns & Hunting

Open letter to Councillor of State Sibylle Jeker on fox hunting

Seven questions to Councillor of State Sibylle Jeker, response deadline 29 September 2026.

Editorial team Wild beim Wild · 15 September 2026

Following her response to the petition calling for a scientific review of fox hunting, IG Wild beim Wild has sent an open letter to Solothurn Councillor of State Sibylle Jeker.

Seven questions, a response deadline of 29 September 2026, and an announcement that the reply will be documented publicly. We reproduce the letter here in full.

On 14 September 2026, Councillor of State Sibylle Jeker, head of the Department of Economic Affairs, rejected the petition submitted by lawyer Pascal Wolf on 15 February 2026 (GK 6900). The letter runs to a single page. It states that fox hunting must serve conflict resolution and describes its contribution to this as «undeniable». At the same time, it explains that an evidence-based approach to fox management would overstretch the canton's resources. The only footnote refers to a position paper by JagdSchweiz, the umbrella association of recreational hunters.

Precisely because the letter is so brief, it can be measured against its own claims: it describes the effect as «undeniable», yet cites no measurable targets, no cantonal data, and no evaluation of results. We set out the facts in our article «Stop fox hunting – write to the Solothurn Cantonal Council», drawing on figures from the Federal Office for the Environment and cantonal hunting statistics, along with a template letter to members of the Cantonal Council.

This open letter follows the same approach as our letters to the President of Lucerne's RUEK Committee, Michael Kurmann, to the Glarus Landammann Markus Heer, to the Uri Department of Security and to Appenzell Outer Rhodes Councillor of State Dölf Biasotto: factual, with concrete questions and the expectation of a verifiable response.

The following open letter was sent to Councillor of State Sibylle Jeker on 15 September 2026. It is reproduced here in full; the subheadings correspond to those in the version sent.

Open letter to Councillor of State Sibylle Jeker

Dear Councillor of State

We have taken note with interest of your response of 14 September 2026 to the petition calling for a review of the scientific necessity of fox hunting (GK 6900). In it, you state that fox hunting must serve conflict resolution and describe its contribution to this as «undeniable». At the same time, you explain that fox management based on scientific evidence would overstretch the canton's staffing and financial resources. These two statements stand in a tension that your letter does not resolve. We would ask you to comment on the following points.

1. «Undeniable», but unsubstantiated

You write that the contribution of hunting and self-help measures to resolving local conflicts with foxes is «undeniable». Yet your letter names neither a measurable cantonal target for fox hunting, nor data on whether such a target has been achieved, nor a scientific source substantiating this contribution. This is exactly what the petition asked about. What cantonal data on wildlife damage, livestock losses, or disease incidence underlies the claim that the contribution of fox hunting is undeniable?

2. Regular hunting and specific conflict cases

Alongside the regular hunting bag, the federal hunting statistics for the canton of Solothurn also record special kills; this category covers in particular kills outside the regular hunting season or within protected areas, for instance in cases of illness or injury. Since 2000, these have numbered at most 19 foxes per year; there were twelve in 2023, and none in 2024 or 2025. By contrast, the regular hunting bag in 2024 amounted to 866 foxes. If the cantonal government justifies fox hunting by reference to local conflict resolution, prevention of wildlife damage, and disease control: which specific conflict cases or target figures justify a regular hunting bag of several hundred foxes per year? And by what criteria does the canton distinguish between targeted intervention in a documented individual case and routine hunting?

3. A hunting association's position paper as the sole source

The only footnote in your letter refers to JagdSchweiz's position paper on fox hunting. JagdSchweiz is the umbrella association of Swiss hunting organisations and represents the interests of those who hunt, including those who hunt foxes. A position paper produced by an interest group is not an independent scientific basis. Did the cantonal government consult independent wildlife-biology literature before drafting its response, and if so, which sources?

4. Legality is not justification

You state that the legal framework sets the boundaries, and reject any «primacy of science». No one has disputed that fox hunting is permitted under federal and cantonal law. The petition did not ask about its legality, but about its benefit. Federal law lists the fox as a huntable species, but does not oblige cantons to pursue regular hunting of it; the canton of Geneva has managed without private hunting since 1974. If the canton of Solothurn explicitly justifies fox hunting on the grounds of preventing wildlife damage and controlling disease, this effect must also be demonstrable. In the view of the cantonal government, why does legal permissibility substitute for evidence of the claimed benefit?

5. The cost argument and the data already available

You state that monitoring as a basis for hunting planning «cannot remotely be achieved with a reasonable amount of staff and cost». The canton of Zug has shown that a scientific stocktaking is possible even without comprehensive population monitoring: the SWILD expert report evaluated existing literature and existing hunting statistics. Both are available in Solothurn; the Office for Forestry, Hunting and Fisheries publishes detailed annual hunting and roadkill/carcass statistics. Your letter presents no analysis of this data. Why was such a stocktaking, following the Zug model, not considered?

6. Decades of high hunting bags, no demonstrated impact assessment

Federal hunting statistics have documented fox hunting in Solothurn since 1933. From 1990 to 2013, hunting bags were mostly between 1,000 and 1,500 foxes per year; in recent years they have been lower, standing at 866 animals in 2024. At the same time, 572 foxes were recorded as roadkill/carcasses in 2024, the highest figure in the available records. Hunting bag and carcass figures alone do not provide direct evidence of population size. But they do raise the question of what effect years of hunting actually achieve. What data does the canton collect, beyond hunting and carcass statistics, to assess the impact of fox hunting on population development, wildlife damage, conflict cases, and disease risk? If no such data exists: why is the effect of hunting nevertheless described as «undeniable»?

7. Disease control without cantonal diagnostic data

You cite disease control as an example of conflict resolution through hunting. Among the publicly available cantonal hunting statistics known to us, the canton of Lucerne records the health status of culled foxes in particular detail: in the 2018/19 hunting year, 39 disease findings were recorded among 2,217 culled foxes, equivalent to 1.76 percent. In Solothurn's 2024 carcass statistics, around 75 of 572 foxes fell into the category «age, illness, weakness». This statistic does not indicate that disease does not occur. But it provides no basis for assuming that a regular hunting bag of 866 foxes is necessary for disease control. Scientific literature further indicates that intensive hunting can increase the prevalence of fox tapeworm (Comte et al. 2017), whereas in Luxembourg a decline was documented following the hunting ban introduced in 2015. What specific data from the canton of Solothurn does the cantonal government rely on when attributing a contribution to disease control to regular fox hunting?

The question your letter leaves unanswered remains: what measurable purpose for the canton of Solothurn justifies a regular fox hunt with several hundred kills per year, when the letter demonstrates neither a goal, nor a data basis, nor any success monitoring? Federal law lists the fox as a huntable species and sets the framework for cantonal hunting regulation. However, it does not oblige the canton to conduct a general regular fox hunt. The canton of Zug has shown that this leeway can be used.

We request a statement from you by 29 September 2026. This letter and any statement you provide will be published on wildbeimwild.com.

Yours sincerely
IG Wild beim Wild

What happens next

If the Cantonal Council responds within the deadline, we will publish and comment on the statement. If no response is received, we will note that as well. Solothurn thus joins a growing series of cantonal disputes over fox hunting. In Lucerne, Glarus, Uri and Appenzell Outer Rhodes, IG Wild beim Wild has confronted authorities with questions about the objective, data basis and effectiveness of fox hunting.

The Cantonal Council describes the benefit of fox hunting as “indisputable”, yet at the same time states that the data basis required for evidence-based management cannot be established with reasonable effort. Our seven questions concern precisely this gap: the objective, data basis and verifiable effect of the regular fox hunt in the canton of Solothurn.

Anyone wishing to take action themselves can find the factual analysis, the FOEN figures and a template letter for members of the cantonal council in our article «Stop fox hunting – write to the Solothurn Cantonal Council». Background information is provided in the overview End fox hunting, on the Geneva model as an example in the article Abolition of recreational hunting following the example of the canton of Geneva and on the psychological dimension of hunting in Solothurn, the article The psychology of recreational hunting in the canton of Solothurn.

More on the subject of recreational hunting: In the dossier Alternatives to recreational hunting we present political and practical alternatives to recreational hunting.

More on the subject of recreational hunting: In the dossier Alternatives to recreational hunting we show political and practical alternatives to recreational hunting. The scientific evidence is presented in the overview Studies on the Effects of Recreational Hunting.

The position of IG Wild beim Wild: IG Wild beim Wild rejects recreational hunting. Our model is the canton of Geneva, which has managed without recreational hunting since 1974: without hunting seasons, without hunting dogs, without driven hunts, without high seats, without the animal cruelty and crime that go hand in hand with hunting season elsewhere. What has worked there for over fifty years disproves every position paper by JagdSchweiz. An association that bases its policy on claims it refutes in its own documents is not a professional organisation, but a factory for misinformation.

All articles are written by IG Wild beim Wild as well as by external co-authors. Research, structuring and editorial processes may be supported by AI-assisted tools.

Support our work

With your donation you help protect animals and give their voice a hearing.

Donate now →