29.10.2026, 06:32

Search

Wild animals

Appenzell Inner Rhodes: wolf kills sheep behind damaged fence

First confirmed livestock kill in the canton since 2024: the canton openly names the shortcoming in herd protection and relies on advice rather than calls for a kill.

Editorial team Wild beim Wild · 29 October 2026
Audio for this article

«No fence, no herder»

0:00 -0:00
All songs

On Monday, 26 October 2026, a wolf killed a sheep in the district of Gonten; according to a press release from the canton of Appenzell Inner Rhodes dated 27 October, the pasture fence was damaged and the flock was therefore “not adequately protected”.

What the canton reports

A farmer discovered the dead sheep on his pasture on Monday morning and alerted the wildlife wardens. During the assessment of the kill, the game warden established “unequivocally” that a wolf was responsible and took DNA samples. According to the canton, it is the first confirmed wolf attack on livestock in Appenzell Inner Rhodes since 2024, when a goat was killed; in January 2026 a wolf was caught on a camera trap. The cantonal herd protection officer warned livestock keepers by text message and is advising them on protective measures, while the wildlife wardens “continue to monitor the situation”. The canton itself draws the lesson: even after long periods without kills, “wolves must be expected in the canton at any time”.

A damaged fence, a familiar pattern

That the canton names the condition of the fence of its own accord is not a given. In Mézery VD, after ewes were killed, it emerged that the enclosure had been secured with two strands instead of the required four. In Ticino, of the 117 livestock killed this year, only six were adequately protected according to official figures, while protection was deemed unreasonable to expect in 52 cases (Ticino ticker, 4 October). And the FOEN has given the Council of Europe written assurances that kills are the last resort and herd protection comes first (What the FOEN assures the Council of Europe).

The legal consequence is clear: under Art. 9b para. 3 of the Hunting Ordinance livestock "for which the reasonable herd protection measures were not properly implemented" are disregarded when assessing damage. A kill behind a defective fence does not count towards an application for a kill permit. A defective fence is therefore not an argument against the wolf, but a finding about husbandry practice. How many sheep in Switzerland actually graze in wildlife habitats, and with what subsidies, has Wild beim Wild set out in «Sheep summering in Switzerland: figures, subsidies, wild animals».

Advice instead of calls for a kill

Inner Rhodes is responding soberly. By comparison: in the Bernese Jura in October, a single calf killed from a protected suckler-cow herd was enough for the canton to issue a kill permit for a lone wolf before the DNA results were available; for large livestock, Art. 9b para. 2 of the Hunting Ordinance allows this after a single animal (watson, 14 October). In Schwyz, the canton had four pups of the Chöpfenberg pack killed, even though the regulation was approved when not a single kill had yet been reported for 2026, and, according to SRF it deployed 200 recreational hunters to support the wildlife wardens (Chöpfenberg pack: four pups dead, the culprits of the kills are not).

In Gonten, by contrast: text messages to livestock keepers, advice, monitoring. That is the sequence the law prescribes and the one the FOEN promises in Strasbourg. Whether the canton holds this line if a second kill follows and the farmers' association or recreational hunting circles grow louder remains to be seen. The first step is the right one: where a sheep dies behind a defective fence, the wolf is not the problem.

More on the subject of recreational hunting: In our dossiers on recreational hunting gather fact-checks, analyses and background reports. What the research says about this is shown by Hunting fact-checked: the state of research.

The position of IG Wild beim Wild: IG Wild beim Wild rejects recreational hunting. Our model is the canton of Geneva, which has managed without recreational hunting since 1974: without hunting seasons, without hunting dogs, without driven hunts, without high seats, without the animal cruelty and crime that go hand in hand with hunting season elsewhere. What has worked there for over fifty years disproves every position paper by JagdSchweiz. An association that bases its policy on claims it refutes in its own documents is not a professional organisation, but a factory for misinformation.

Wild animals need a voice

Once a week: research, petitions and background information on recreational hunting. Free of charge and can be unsubscribed from at any time.

All articles are written by IG Wild beim Wild as well as by external co-authors. Research, structuring and editorial processes may be supported by AI-assisted tools.

Support our work

With your donation you help protect animals and give their voice a hearing.

Donate now →