Türkheim: Recreational hunter had already shot a crow during the closed season in June
The 23-year-old who mistook two pregnant cows for wild boars had already come to attention in the summer with a shot fired during the closed season. The hunting ground manager calls the case “negligent”, while also pointing to the pressure of wild boar hunting.
Stock image. Photo: Juaquin Troncoso / Unsplash
Mistaken for a Red Deer
The 23-year-old recreational hunter who shot two pregnant cows near Türkheim in the Unterallgäu at the beginning of November had already come to the attention of the police. As the “Augsburger Allgemeine” reports, at the beginning of June he had shot a crow near the Türkheim golf course, even though it was the closed season. The police investigated on suspicion of an offence under the Animal Welfare Act; according to the newspaper, this case is still open.
Two incidents within five months
In the early morning of 5 November, the man had fired two shots at two cows which, by his own account, he took for wild boars in the dark. Both died shortly before calving. We have set out the sequence of events and the facts known so far in the article Türkheim: recreational hunter mistakes two pregnant cows for wild boars.
This means that, within roughly five months, two incidents involving the same recreational hunter are the focus of police investigations. On the crow case, Franz Baur, who manages the hunting ground as deputy to the lease holder, told the newspaper that the bird was injured and that the 23-year-old wanted to “put it out of its misery” in the afternoon. Whether the shot fired during the closed season was therefore lawful is not answered by this account. The presumption of innocence applies in both cases.
“Negligent”, but with a reference to the pressure
Baur himself calls the shot at the cows “negligent and a huge mistake”. At the same time, he spoke of a wild boar problem in the region, which is why “the pressure on hunters” is high. After inspecting the spot, he said he could understand how a mix-up could happen in principle in the tall-growing field.
The letters to the editor in the regional press are unambiguous, including from hunters themselves. One reader, who says he hunts in two hunting grounds between Rammingen and Mindelheim, points out that before every shot the species, sex, age and condition of the animal must be clearly established, and concludes: «There is no excuse for this.» Another demands that the hunting licence and all firearms permits be withdrawn for life. Two residents of Türkheim tell Baur that dark outlines are «no reason to pull the trigger».
What German firearms law provides
Repeated or gross violations of, among other things, the Weapons Act or the Federal Hunting Act can, under Section 5(2) no. 5 of the German Weapons Act, justify a finding that a person is unreliable under firearms law. Where reliability is lacking, the hunting licence must also be refused or withdrawn (Sections 17 and 18 of the Federal Hunting Act). What consequences will follow in the Türkheim case, and whether the responsible district office is examining measures under hunting or firearms law, remains unclear on the basis of the reporting so far.
Comment: Pressure is no excuse
The reference to heavy hunting pressure does not answer the decisive question: why was the shot fired when the animals apparently had not been reliably identified? Anyone who, after two dead pregnant cows, stresses the «pressure on hunters» must explain how safety requirements are to be prevented from taking a back seat. The basic rule of every hunter training course knows no exception for pressure: whatever is not identified beyond doubt is not shot at. Baur's own assessment, «negligent and a huge mistake», underlines how serious the incident is.
The fact that the same recreational hunter had already come to attention in the summer for a shot fired during the closed season does not make the case any smaller. Authorities must check reliability before two incidents become three, as the example of a recreational hunter from Trentino shows, whose weapons were confiscated after just one fit of rage. And the problem is not a Bavarian one: why shots at dusk and at night are fundamentally a risk is shown by our dossier on night hunting and high-tech, while a push against it is provided by the Template text: No recreational hunting at dusk and at night.
Seen something yourself?
A driven hunt next to a hiking trail, a shot fired near houses, a trap in the forest or an injured wild animal: report it to the Recreational Hunter Radar. We check every tip-off and treat your details confidentially.
More on the subject of recreational hunting: In the dossier Poaching and hunting crime in Switzerland we document cases, legal questions and recurring patterns. The scientific evidence is presented in the overview Studies on the Effects of Recreational Hunting.
The position of IG Wild beim Wild: IG Wild beim Wild rejects recreational hunting. Our model is the canton of Geneva, which has managed without recreational hunting since 1974: without hunting seasons, without hunting dogs, without driven hunts, without high seats, without the animal cruelty and crime that go hand in hand with hunting season elsewhere. What has worked there for over fifty years disproves every position paper by JagdSchweiz. An association that bases its policy on claims it refutes in its own documents is not a professional organisation, but a factory for misinformation.
Wild animals need a voice
Once a week: investigations, petitions and background on recreational hunting. As a thank-you, you will immediately receive our free guide “Recreational hunting on your doorstep: what you can do”. Free of charge and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Support our work
With your donation you help protect animals and give their voice a hearing.
Donate now →